How to peer review an essay example

When you write a peer review for a manuscript, what should you include in your comments? What should you leave out? And how should the review be formatted?

how to peer review an essay example

This will also help you keep your comments organized. Think about structuring your review essxy an inverted pyramid. Put the most important information at the top, followed by details and examples in the center, and any additional points at the very bottom.

Giving Feedback

In your own words, summarize what the manuscript claims to report. This shows the editor how you interpreted the manuscript and will highlight any major differences in leer between you and the other reviewers. End this section with your recommended course of action.

Within each section, you can talk about the biggest issues first or go systematically figure-by-figure or claim-by-claim.

Basic tenets of peer reviewing:

Number each item so that your points are easy to follow this revuew also make it easier for the authors to respond to each point. Major issues should consist of the essential points the authors need to address before the manuscript can proceed. Make sure you focus on what is fundamental for the current study. Minor issues are still important but typically will not affect the overall conclusions of the manuscript.

Giving an effective peer review: sample framework and comments

Some journals have a space for reviewers to enter confidential comments about the manuscript. Any serious issues should be raised directly and immediately with the journal as well.

Do not use this space to critique the manuscript, since comments entered here will not be passed along to the authors. If you are reviewing for a journal that does not offer a space for confidential comments, consider writing to the editorial office directly with your concerns.

how to peer review an essay example

Giving feedback is hard. Giving effective how to peer review an essay example can pesr even more challenging. Remember that your ultimate goal is to discuss what the authors would need to do in order to qualify for publication. The point is not to nitpick every piece of the manuscript.

Your focus should be on providing constructive and critical feedback that the authors can use to improve their study. Even if you decide not to identify yourself in the review, you should write comments that you would be comfortable signing your name to.]

how to peer review an essay example